❋
The Prewitt
Restaurant + lounge
The Prewitt Restaurant + Lounge is one of downtown Plainfield’s signature destinations for dining, live music, and memorable nights out. Thoughtfully restored in 2021 after nearly a century of history, the building blends preserved vintage character with a fresh, modern energy.
Today, The Prewitt operates as a restaurant, lounge, and live entertainment venue, offering locally inspired cuisine, craft cocktails, and a vibrant gathering space under its iconic marquee. It’s a place where historic charm meets elevated experiences—honoring its roots while creating new stories in the heart of Main Street.
❋ ARCHITECTURAL OVERVIEW
The Prewitt is a classic early 20th century two story brick commercial building that reflects the traditional Main Street architecture common throughout small town Indiana. Its red brick façade, symmetrical upper story, and pedestrian focused storefront preserve the historic rhythm of downtown Plainfield, while the iconic marquee projecting over the sidewalk highlights its long standing role as a place for entertainment and gathering. The 2021 restoration maintained the building’s original masonry character and proportions while thoughtfully integrating modern lighting, signage, and interior updates to support its current use as a restaurant, lounge, and live music venue.
❋ History and timeline
1906: Joseph E. Prewitt (likely to be related to later theater owner) becomes the first person in Plainfield to own an automobile.
1914 (October): J.E. Prewitt begins erecting a garage on his lot between the post office and First National Bank (119 West Main Street).
Spring 1915: Prewitt's Motor Sales (garage selling Goodrich tires and serving National Road travelers) opens at 119 West Main Street.
1918: Garage business expands (later to 211 West Main; Lowell Prewitt involved in operations).
1924: The predecessor storefront Princess Theatre on the site closes.
February 1927: L.M. (Lowell M.) Prewitt announces plans to build a modern movie theater; he temporarily operates the ZaZa Theatre (101 East Main) while construction proceeds.
November 23–26, 1927: The Prewitt Theatre opens with the film No Place to Go (starring Mary Astor and Lloyd Hughes). It features a white enameled brick façade, green Spanish tile roof, Moorish vaulted tiled lobby, hardwood floors, and seating for ~400. Built in simple Spanish style (L.M. Prewitt also credited as architect); local labor/materials used. Locally also referred to as Village Theater early on.
1928: Lowell and Janet Prewitt open the Sweet Shoppe; new ventilation system and electric clock added above box office.
1929: First "talkie" (Voice of the City) shown in Hendricks County; acoustic panels added; lobby retail (C.L. Jessup store); Janet opens Frock Shoppe; soundproofing and new screen installed.
1930: Promotional appearance by MGM's Leo the lion.
1931: Ticket prices reduced (10¢/25¢); free Christmas movies for schoolchildren; third story added with two-floor apartment above theater for the Prewitts; marquee repainted (red lights, white/green trim through ~1934).
1934: Lowell Prewitt dies at age 40; Janet Prewitt continues managing.
1938: Air-conditioning installed.
1940: Gone with the Wind draws large crowds.
1942 & 1948: Seats recovered/reupholstered.
1944: New projectors installed; popular films include Lassie Come Home; during WWII, the theater desegregates after advocacy (local account credits Cassie Swarn persuading Janet Prewitt, noting Black soldiers' service).
1949: Ailing Janet leases to Guy and Beatrice Hancock (Guy dies 1952; Beatrice continues).
1959: Beatrice Hancock purchases the building (Janet Prewitt dies same year).
1967: Renamed Cinema West under Clyde Nihiser.
1970: Brief run as arthouse/X-rated films (met with local disapproval; did not last long).
1971–1972: Renamed Village Theater, later Village West Theater; operated with mainstream films.
~1980s–2005: Continued operation (name variations); ownership changes include Banc One (1988 after Tudor Amusement Corp. issues/bankruptcy), Plainfield Chamber of Commerce (1994), others (Michael Freeman, CLF Properties LLC). Frank Katris purchases in February 2002 hoping to revive with family films; renovation plans stall amid competition from new multiplex at Metropolis Mall. Closed in 2005 (as Village West Theatre); sat vacant/disrepair afterward. (Note: Some sources mention 1980s closure, but multiple local/news accounts confirm ~2003–2005 with photos/plans around 2003–2006.)
Adjacent/connected property (121 West Main Street, now integrated): Built 1903 as a bank (robbery 1924); Joseph Prewitt buys ~1930 and adds apartment; later uses include mortuary (Hall Mortuary), beauty shop, apparel store (Lyon & Lyon until 1959); ownership ties to theater through Prewitt heirs, Hancocks, etc.; later businesses before 2018 town acquisition.
2018: Plainfield Redevelopment Commission/Town of Plainfield acquires the property (~$335,000); restores historic marquee, clears basement tanks; feasibility studies for reuse.
2021: Sold to Keller Huff Restaurant Group (Patrick Keller, Doug Huff); both 119/121 buildings renovated/merged into The Prewitt Restaurant & Lounge (preserving art deco/vintage theater elements, marquee, stage/screen area; features dining, bar, live entertainment, events; reopened with American fare, cocktails, movie-themed nods).
❋ key references and sources
Plainfield-Guilford Township Public Library genealogy page (most detailed chronological property history).
https://www.plainfieldlibrary.net/services/genealogy/house-property-history/prewitt-theatre/
Cinema Treasures entry (opening, seating, name changes, closure, ownership).
https://cinematreasures.org/theaters/15351
Official Prewitt Dining "About" page (high-level history and conversion).
Facebook Group: You might be from PLAINFIELD, INDIANA if. . .
https://www.facebook.com/groups/151431394936936/posts/2965882603491787/
Local news (Reporter.net, WRTV, Visit Hendricks County, etc.) confirming 1927 opening, Village name/2005 closure, 2018–2021 revival.
A very special thank you to Main Street Plainfield Board Member, Feng Xue, for researching, collecting and writing The Prewitt Restaurant + Lounge Historic page.
Historic storytelling made possible with a grant from Indiana Humanities and Indiana Landmarks.